• New Cars
    • First Impressions
    • Road Tests
  • Classics
    • Classic Profiles
    • Classic Driving Impressions
    • Classics Information
    • Events and Days Out
  • Motoring For Fun
  • News & Views
  • Bookshelf
  • Technical
    • Grumpy Old Mechanic
    • Kim’s Tips
  • Features
    • Visits
    • Track Days
  • Contributors
    • About our contributors
    • Kim Henson
    • Chris Adamson
    • Kieron Fennelly
    • Ant Henson
    • Rachel Henson
    • David Miles
    • Gerald Morgan
    • Dave Moss
    • Dave Randle
    • Robin Roberts
    • Tom Scanlan
    • Glen Smale
    • Keith Ward
    • John Price Williams
  • More…
    • About Wheels Alive
    • Tips for using this website
    • Useful Links
  • A-Z

Wheels Alive

Old cars, new cars, borrowed cars & blue cars. If it steers it's here!

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Book Review – The Perfect Car

Author/Source: Kieron Fennelly

11th August 2018

The Perfect Car…

Reviewed by Kieron Fennelly.

Title: The Perfect Car (The Biography of John Barnard)

Author: Nick Skeens

Published by: Evro Publishing www.evropublishing.com

591 pages; hardback

Price: £40 UK; $60 USA.

ISBN: 978-1-910505-27-4

John Barnard’s remarkable design career encompassed two periods at McLaren, plus two stints at Ferrari as well as working for the Americans Parnelli Jones and Jim Hall and turning Benetton into the team which gave Schumacher his first world championship. An extraordinarily impressive CV by any standards, but what makes the book is the character of its subject.

John Barnard is a perfectionist: Today he readily admits that he could have enjoyed more championship success (and earned more money) if he had stuck to a winning combination. But he didn’t: “Tweaking” as he puts it bored him. He needed the oxygen of an entirely new challenge. He could have stayed at McLaren, he could even have remained at Ferrari, which as he puts it, has been the only consistent game in the F1 town over seventy years.

Barnard’s inventiveness knew no limits. His consistent refusal to accept the engineering status quo meant he redesigned Parnelli Jones’s gearbox to run at 90º to the crankshaft so that the car’s aerodynamics would not be compromised. No one had attempted a transverse competition gearbox before.

At Ferrari, he was frustrated by the cockpit space required for the gearshift, which increased width and interfered with all-important aerodynamics, so his dispensed with the manual shift, narrowing the car and devised the now ubiquitous steering wheel buttons. If eventually he succeeded in overcoming the objections of a ‘not invented here’ Ferrari engineering establishment, it took huge and ultimately exhausting determination. Yet after resigning once, Maranello asked Barnard back, but not before Ron Dennis had offered him a deal to return to McLaren, an approach not made public at the time. Concerned that his independence would be restricted under Martin Whitmarsh, Barnard turned down the chance to work again for the firm where his pioneering use of carbon fibre elevated McLaren to the pinnacle of motor racing and made him personally famous.

Author Nick Skeens readily admits he knew nothing about motor sport before meeting John Barnard and he acknowledges the contribution of Formula 1 specialists like Mark Hughes who proofread his texts. The result is a book which has the feel of the insider yet without the insider’s sometimes obtrusive tendency to add his own view of events. On a technical level too, Skeens hits a happy medium between sufficient detail to please the informed yet keeping the work accessible to the ‘lay’ reader. This approach helps to make the descriptions of how Barnard discovered carbon fibre in particular, compelling reading.

Another strand in the book is Barnard’s difficult relationship with Ron Dennis, the former racing mechanic who took over McLaren in the late 1970s, two brilliant men with sometimes divergent views. This eventually drove the single-minded Barnard to Ferrari, where the primitiveness of some of its engineering practices were a surprise and where, and rather less surprisingly, he fell victim to Modena’s infamous politics as had so many before him. Impressively, Barnard now accepts his dogmatic approach did not always serve him whether it was falling out with Dennis, or rejecting the latter’s olive branch, where he “flounced out, possibly his greatest mistake,” or insisting on working for Ferrari from his Woking base.

Skeen has clearly researched widely and if the clunking phrase “in an interview for this book” recurs with monotonous frequency, this styling lapse is forgivable when the contributions themselves add so much to the understanding of John Barnard. Indeed, the story builds to a remarkable climax where the author realises that the work cannot be complete without the views of Ron Dennis and he engineers a meeting between him and Barnard. Skeens’s trepidation, indeed excitement as he accompanies Barnard’s visit to Dennis’s home is palpable and the subsequent dialogue is utterly absorbing, providing a very satisfying dénouement to a work which at times reads like a novel. Barnard has bravely opened himself to a warts and all interpretation of his life. The result is an intelligent and fascinating work in which the subject grows on our estimation.

VERDICT

An exceptional and thorough biography for which Nick Skeens deserves congratulation.

Save Post as PDF

Categories: Bookshelf, Kieron Fennelly

Tip: For improved search accuracy, enclose search terms for multiple words in quotation marks. For example:
"Land Rover".

Advertise with us
A-ZPlease visit the A-Z page for listings by make, model, year etc. and an advanced search form.

Recent Posts

E-fuels’ environmental credentials under discussion in Europe

Audi TT quattro sport – just so much fun

Austin Seven Centenary celebrated this summer at The British Motor Museum

Splendid Standards at Cranfield

Are electric cars the answer to today’s higher than ever cost of motoring?

Ford Escort Mark I – Stolen; has anyone seen it?

Synthetic fuels evaluated in historic racing car

Volkswagen Taigo – Road Test

Contributors

contributors

Our well-respected contributors live and breathe motor cars; aren’t we lucky?

Contributors to the site include talented, highly-respected people (so they tell me) on the hallowed membership list of the Guild of Motoring Writers, and from the similarly well thought-of Western Group of Motoring Writers. In addition there are valued contributions from other knowledgeable and capable motoring writers who have something useful to say about all aspects of driving and running vehicles in the 21st Century. All of our team are passionate about motor cars!


Read about our contributors  ››

Popular Tags

4x4 all-electric Audi Austin Beaulieu BMW Book review Bookshelf British Motor Museum City car Compact SUV Convertible Coupé crossover Electric Electric Cars electric vehicle estate Estate car EV five door estate five door hatchback Ford four door saloon hatchback Hot hatch hot hatchback Hybrid Hybrid SUV Kia large SUV luxury SUV Mazda MG mid-size SUV Mini Motor Ombudsman MPV National Motor Museum news News round-up Nissan People carrier PHEV plug-in hybrid saloon self-charging hybrid Seven seater SUV sports car Sports saloon sporty hatchback sporty SUV supercar Supermini SUV Suzuki The Motor Ombudsman three door hatchback Tyres VW
All Tags ››

Wheels Alive Social

  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Like us on Facebook

Like us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

My Tweets

Contact us

We welcome your questions, comments and feedback. Please click here to contact us.

Advertising Opportunities

Please contact us if you would like to discuss advertising opportunities on Wheels Alive.

Please share our website

Copyright © 2022 Kim Henson, Wheels Alive